The curious lack of type inference support in C# constructors

Check out my new course Learn you some Lambda best practice for great good! and learn the best practices for performance, cost, security, resilience, observability and scalability.

Given a generic class in C# like this one:

public class MyType<T>
    public MyType(T value) { }

You will need to specify what the type T should be when you call the constructor:

var myObj = new MyType<int>(42);

The compiler is not able to use type inference to infer the type T to be int.

Now, this is interesting as type inference is supported by any other generic method, so if you were to create a factory class for MyType<T> you could indeed make use of type inference like this:

public class MyTypeFactory
    public static MyType<T> Create<T>(T value)
        return new MyType<T>(value);
var myObj = MyTypeFactory.Create(42); // returns MyType<int>

Some argue that it’s not possible because of the possible presence of other overloaded constructors (or for that matter a non-generic version of MyType), but at the end of the day the constructor is a method like any other and the cited ambiguity can also appear with normal generic methods:

public void Foo(short value) {}
public void Foo(int value) {}
public void Foo(long value) {}
public void Foo(double value) {}
public void Foo<T>(T value) {}
Foo(42); // which Foo is called? Foo(int) of course!

So amidst all that ambiguity the compiler is able to infer the type for the Foo method, so what’s so special about the constructor? Am I missing something obvious here?

Luckily, as Eric Lippert stated in his answer to my question here, the reason the constructor does not support type inference is a practical one – the benefit of the feature does not out-weight the cost of its implementation and it is some way behind other possible features in terms of priority. Whilst he did say that this feature is on the list, considering that the ‘theme’ of the next C# release (5.0) is rumoured to be meta-programming, there’s a good chance we won’t be seeing type inference in the C# constructor for some time yet!


Jon Skeet’s Brainteasers + Answers

StackOverflow question – why can’t the C# constructor infer type

Liked this article? Support me on Patreon and get direct help from me via a private Slack channel or 1-2-1 mentoring.
Subscribe to my newsletter

Hi, I’m Yan. I’m an AWS Serverless Hero and the author of Production-Ready Serverless.

I specialise in rapidly transitioning teams to serverless and building production-ready services on AWS.

Are you struggling with serverless or need guidance on best practices? Do you want someone to review your architecture and help you avoid costly mistakes down the line? Whatever the case, I’m here to help.

Hire me.

Check out my new podcast Real-World Serverless where I talk with engineers who are building amazing things with serverless technologies and discuss the real-world use cases and challenges they face. If you’re interested in what people are actually doing with serverless and what it’s really like to be working with serverless day-to-day, then this is the podcast for you.

Check out my new course, Learn you some Lambda best practice for great good! In this course, you will learn best practices for working with AWS Lambda in terms of performance, cost, security, scalability, resilience and observability. We will also cover latest features from re:Invent 2019 such as Provisioned Concurrency and Lambda Destinations. Enrol now and start learning!

Check out my video course, Complete Guide to AWS Step Functions. In this course, we’ll cover everything you need to know to use AWS Step Functions service effectively. There is something for everyone from beginners to more advanced users looking for design patterns and best practices. Enrol now and start learning!

Are you working with Serverless and looking for expert training to level-up your skills? Or are you looking for a solid foundation to start from? Look no further, register for my Production-Ready Serverless workshop to learn how to build production-grade Serverless applications!

Find a workshop near you