Interesting observation on C# 4’s optional parameter

The other day I had an interesting observation on the optional parameters in C# 4, whereby if you specify a parameter as optional on an interface you don’t actually have to make that parameter optional on any implementing class:

   1: public interface MyInterface

   2: {

   3:     void TestMethod(bool flag=false);

   4: }

   5:

   6: public class MyClass : MyInterface

   7: {

   8:     public void TestMethod(bool flag)

   9:     {

  10:         Console.WriteLine(flag);

  11:     }

  12: }

Which means you won’t be able to use the implementing class and the interface interchangeably:

   1: var obj = new MyClass();

   2: obj.TestMethod(); // compiler error

   3:

   4: var obj2 = new MyClass() as MyInterface;

   5: obj2.TestMethod(); // prints false

Naturally, this bags the question of why the compiler doesn’t enforce the implementation to match the default value specified by the contract?

Luckily, my subsequent question on SO was answered by Eric Lippert from the C# compiler team, not to waste time and effort repeating what’s already been said, check out his answer and it’s clear to see the rationale here and why it would be impractical and inconvenient should the compiler does it differently.

References:

My question on StackOverflow

Article on positives and pitfalls of using optional parameters

Enjoy what you’re reading? Subscribe to my newsletter and get more content on AWS and serverless technologies delivered straight to your inbox.


Yan Cui

I’m an AWS Serverless Hero and the author of Production-Ready Serverless. I have run production workload at scale in AWS for nearly 10 years and I have been an architect or principal engineer with a variety of industries ranging from banking, e-commerce, sports streaming to mobile gaming. I currently work as an independent consultant focused on AWS and serverless.

You can contact me via Email, Twitter and LinkedIn.

Hire me.


Check out my new course, Complete Guide to AWS Step Functions.

In this course, we’ll cover everything you need to know to use AWS Step Functions service effectively. Including basic concepts, HTTP and event triggers, activities, design patterns and best practices.

Get Your Copy